In football practice, there is a continuous need to evaluate the quality of the performance of football kicks. In order to increase quality of new coaching plans, it is important to apply simpler and more technologically advanced tools for testing purposes. The point of this hypothesis was to determine the reliability and discriminatory validity of a simple testing protocol for the accuracy, speed, and quality of football kicks with the MyKicks application in senior football players. A special sample of 17 football players competing in the 2nd football league, with an average age of 22.2 ± 2.9 years, and 15 football players competing in the 5th football league, with an average age of 24.4 ± 6.8 years, participated in the research. Reliability was evaluated by comparing the individual and group results of two consecutive (first and repeated) tests, and the discriminant validity was evaluated by comparing the results of a group of higher-level football players and a group of lower-level football players. The results showed that the proposed protocol was reliable enough to test ball speed in professional-level footballers, but not amateur-level ones. In addition, the test with a medium level of reliability can also be used to rank footballers according to the accuracy and quality of the shots that hit the goal. However, the proposed protocol, in the applied format, is not valid enough to evaluate the authentic situational accuracy and quality of the kick in football. Future studies have yet to determine whether other protocols that, using the MyKicks tool, can adequately quantify failed attempts and reliably and validly evaluate the skill of punches in amateur and professional football players.